Black Editions: End of an era, or 997 refined??
#15
02-15-2011, 03:45 PM
You have to think of it this way. Here are all of the special 997's we've had.
Club Coupe
Sport Classic
Speedster
GT2 RS
Black Edition
Black Edition Cabriolet
It's really not that many, but in addition to the 18 standard production 911s, it seems like a lot. IMHO, the Sport Classic, Speedster, and GT2 RS were all substantially different from the cars they were based on, and deserve a spot in the 911 lineup. The Carrera GTS is also deserving of a spot. The Black Editions though, don't deserve a spot at all. They're pointless.
Besides these dumb Black Editions, I don't get all of the hate for the 997. I always see people complaining about how much they hate all of these special editions, yet I see them professing their love to some of the special editions in other threads.
Jox, I want to ask, what do you think would be the ideal 997 lineup? You seem to have a very valid opinion on this subject (not a joke lineup, serious).
Club Coupe
Sport Classic
Speedster
GT2 RS
Black Edition
Black Edition Cabriolet
It's really not that many, but in addition to the 18 standard production 911s, it seems like a lot. IMHO, the Sport Classic, Speedster, and GT2 RS were all substantially different from the cars they were based on, and deserve a spot in the 911 lineup. The Carrera GTS is also deserving of a spot. The Black Editions though, don't deserve a spot at all. They're pointless.
Besides these dumb Black Editions, I don't get all of the hate for the 997. I always see people complaining about how much they hate all of these special editions, yet I see them professing their love to some of the special editions in other threads.
Jox, I want to ask, what do you think would be the ideal 997 lineup? You seem to have a very valid opinion on this subject (not a joke lineup, serious).
#16
02-15-2011, 03:51 PM
My opinion, give us the RS 4.0, stop making 997's and bring out the 991! Start with the basic C2, C2 Cab, C2S, C4S, etc. Eliminate the Targa model by turning it into an option on 991 coupes (which I think Porsche is going to do judging by spyshots, my fear though is that it's standard), and then introduce a Turbo/Turbo Cab and GT3 the following year, roll out a GT3 RS and GT2, and then be done with it, unless they can think of a limited edition actually worth producing. Then, start the cycle all over again with the 991.2, add in a GT2 RS, and then give us the 992!
#17
02-15-2011, 05:54 PM
My opinion, give us the RS 4.0, stop making 997's and bring out the 991! Start with the basic C2, C2 Cab, C2S, C4S, etc. Eliminate the Targa model by turning it into an option on 991 coupes (which I think Porsche is going to do judging by spyshots, my fear though is that it's standard), and then introduce a Turbo/Turbo Cab and GT3 the following year, roll out a GT3 RS and GT2, and then be done with it, unless they can think of a limited edition actually worth producing. Then, start the cycle all over again with the 991.2, add in a GT2 RS, and then give us the 992!
#18
02-15-2011, 06:00 PM
It has some 'value' to it; but they're just phasing out the 997. Which is a shame; instead of 'special editions- they should offer a 2 or 3 day course at Skip Barber so they can really learn how to drive a 911.
That's what builds passion for the brand. Track Days!
That's what builds passion for the brand. Track Days!
#19
02-15-2011, 06:09 PM
Teamspeed Pro
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Burlington, Ontario/Marco Island, Fl.
Posts: 3,798
I'll refrain from anything substantial and use the words I really want to, since this is a strategic partner thread, but let's just say that the 997 platform has successfully turned what used to be my favorite brand into the biggest whore the automotive world has ever seen. It's gotten to a point where I'd rather go and punch whoever's responsible for this over at Porsche HQ than visiting the museum in Stuttgart.
I mean, hell - it used to be fun to poke around at Porsche's absolutely hysterical ways to milk everything they could out of the platform, but that was around 20 variants ago. Now it's just outrageously pathetic and downright insulting. If they found as much as an odd bolt on the part shelves they'd put it in a limited number of cars and call it the "obscure bolt edition".
Somebody burn down the warehouse where they keep 997 assembly line already so we can get something else for a change.
I mean, hell - it used to be fun to poke around at Porsche's absolutely hysterical ways to milk everything they could out of the platform, but that was around 20 variants ago. Now it's just outrageously pathetic and downright insulting. If they found as much as an odd bolt on the part shelves they'd put it in a limited number of cars and call it the "obscure bolt edition".
Somebody burn down the warehouse where they keep 997 assembly line already so we can get something else for a change.
