woo hoo I've seen both in person, haven;t driven both but from every review under the sun there really is no difference between the two....except a few $k. Fifth Gear Porsche Cayman R Full Test Review S19E09 - YouTube

 

To be honest, i was basing it on looks alone hahahahaha.....how many of us are going to be able to push our cars to 10-10ths and notice the 10hp and the drop in weight? Not me. I just want something that is quick and fun and looks awesome! I think both cars do that really well....perhaps the R a little more but this all black/clean look is def nice I dont think you can wrong....

 

That's what I've heard too... The weight saving difference would most likely be imperceptible and both are rated at 330hp, the BE got the 10 hp bump too. As far as resale goes, I think you're better off going with the Black Edition, because of it's special edition status and that there are only going to be 100 in the country.