996 vs 997 reliability as a daily driver?
#11
Hi all!
I'm looking to buy a used 996 or 997 as a daily driver, and was wondering how the majority of you fared with your cars.
On various Porsche forums, I've thus far been terrified of the 997 as it seems that hundreds of owners have had their engines replaced at low kms -- two huge problems appear to be an "intermediate shaft failure" requiring complete engine replacement, and also failures of cylinder liner in Cyl 5 or 6...
In comparison I haven't found many other huge issues with the 996?
For reference, I've driven a Lexus for about 5 years and haven't had a single problem, so I'm hesitant to take the plunge!
Any input would be greatly appreciated!
I'm looking to buy a used 996 or 997 as a daily driver, and was wondering how the majority of you fared with your cars.
On various Porsche forums, I've thus far been terrified of the 997 as it seems that hundreds of owners have had their engines replaced at low kms -- two huge problems appear to be an "intermediate shaft failure" requiring complete engine replacement, and also failures of cylinder liner in Cyl 5 or 6...
In comparison I haven't found many other huge issues with the 996?
For reference, I've driven a Lexus for about 5 years and haven't had a single problem, so I'm hesitant to take the plunge!
Any input would be greatly appreciated!
#13
I will have had my 997 Turbo for 4 years in November. That is hard to believe.
It has been nothing short of a dream. I have spent a grand total of about $2,000 on maintenance - including bi-annual oil changes and a scheduled, full OEM brake job.
The car now has a little over 18,000 miles on it and has never given me a minute's trouble.
I should add that I have a TON of mods on the car including race exhaust and a methanol injection kit.
I have no idea where you are getting your whacky information, but my experience has been that these cars are basically bulletproof.
It has been nothing short of a dream. I have spent a grand total of about $2,000 on maintenance - including bi-annual oil changes and a scheduled, full OEM brake job.
The car now has a little over 18,000 miles on it and has never given me a minute's trouble.
I should add that I have a TON of mods on the car including race exhaust and a methanol injection kit.
I have no idea where you are getting your whacky information, but my experience has been that these cars are basically bulletproof.
#14
The issue that you are referring to is mainly an issue only on the earlier 996 N/A versions. The IMS issue is still pretty rare, even on the most affected early 996 N/A cars. This problem has also been brought up on the 986 and 987 platform-also which is on the rarer side of occurrence.
Both the 996 and 997tt with their metzger engine's have very little issues but there are rare cases as always. The 996/997 gt3's have issues with their RMS leaking but that is usually only if they are tracked heavily and even if so is not really a big issue.
Both the 996 and 997tt with their metzger engine's have very little issues but there are rare cases as always. The 996/997 gt3's have issues with their RMS leaking but that is usually only if they are tracked heavily and even if so is not really a big issue.
#15
I have a 2006 911c2 Cab, manual and use it daily. It's my only car and have never had a major problem! Flat tire once and worn tire replacement that's it. 37,000 miles. it's just like every other car. You have to maintain it properly. Enjoy life!
#17
Thanks for the input guys!
I went down to a local euro garage and the manager informed me that about 5% of 996/997/Boxsters suffered intermediate shaft failure, resulting in engine destruction. It isn't actually the shaft that fails, but a round bearing that houses the shaft. Porsche apparently made the bearing sealed with grease for life, but it apparently wasn't made well enough. Although this was actually a huge issue, Porsche never formally issued a recall or addressed the issue. Turbo 996/997s are not affected as they have a different bearing that houses this shaft, while early model (97-200x)Boxsters have highest frequency of this problem.
The manager told me that the best option is to have the IMS bearing replaced or upgraded to stronger aftermarket ones when the clutch is being replaced.
I went down to a local euro garage and the manager informed me that about 5% of 996/997/Boxsters suffered intermediate shaft failure, resulting in engine destruction. It isn't actually the shaft that fails, but a round bearing that houses the shaft. Porsche apparently made the bearing sealed with grease for life, but it apparently wasn't made well enough. Although this was actually a huge issue, Porsche never formally issued a recall or addressed the issue. Turbo 996/997s are not affected as they have a different bearing that houses this shaft, while early model (97-200x)Boxsters have highest frequency of this problem.
The manager told me that the best option is to have the IMS bearing replaced or upgraded to stronger aftermarket ones when the clutch is being replaced.
#19
Last edited by Badandy; Nov 13, 2011 at 02:28 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
astonmartinone77
General Automotive & SUV Forum
178
Jan 27, 2012 04:29 PM
Bookmarks
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)





red is the sexiest color. 







