The Mid- vs. Rear-Engine Debate: Porsche Cayman R vs. 911 GT3 by Car & Driver
#1
The Mid- vs. Rear-Engine Debate: Porsche Cayman R vs. 911 GT3 by Car & Driver
The Mid- vs. Rear-Engine Debate: Porsche Cayman R vs. 911 GT3
Car & Driver pits these two hardcore Porsche against each other
Porsche’s 2012 Cayman R, the hottest mid-engined model in Porsche’s current lineup, represents the theory side of the equation. This is the thinking man’s sports car—light, stripped, and hunkered down for utmost agility. Aluminum door skins, a bare-bones interior, carbon-fiber seat structures, and new 19-inch wheels hold the curb weight to 3076 pounds. Air conditioning and audio-entertainment equipment are optional. Porsche’s 3.4-liter, direct-injection flat-six has been goaded to 330 horsepower at 7400 rpm, a 10-hp gain over the standard Cayman S. While price doesn’t count in this analysis, the Cayman R starts at $67,250, a pocket-warming $12,700 less than a base 911.
We tapped a 911 GT3—the proud son in an unbroken line of rear-engined Porsches dating back to 1948—to represent the practice-makes-perfect argument. What the GT3 lacks in value (as-tested price: $130,910), it overcomes with pure grit. In terms of power-to-weight ratio, this is the second-hottest naturally aspirated Porsche money can buy (after the GT3 RS). The 435-hp, 3.8-liter flat-six and the six-speed transaxle powering this 911 descend from battle-hardened race hardware. Prepped GT3s compete in the Porsche Supercup, a Formula 1 support series. Decades of exorcising handling gremlins that come with hanging a 570-pound engine behind the rear axle have paid off in razor-edged reflexes. The latest fix is a $1300 set of dynamic engine mounts that cinch up during aggressive maneuvers to calm the GT3’s transient behavior.
We tapped a 911 GT3—the proud son in an unbroken line of rear-engined Porsches dating back to 1948—to represent the practice-makes-perfect argument. What the GT3 lacks in value (as-tested price: $130,910), it overcomes with pure grit. In terms of power-to-weight ratio, this is the second-hottest naturally aspirated Porsche money can buy (after the GT3 RS). The 435-hp, 3.8-liter flat-six and the six-speed transaxle powering this 911 descend from battle-hardened race hardware. Prepped GT3s compete in the Porsche Supercup, a Formula 1 support series. Decades of exorcising handling gremlins that come with hanging a 570-pound engine behind the rear axle have paid off in razor-edged reflexes. The latest fix is a $1300 set of dynamic engine mounts that cinch up during aggressive maneuvers to calm the GT3’s transient behavior.
#2
Wow. Moral victory for the Cayman. Way less sticky tires, smaller contact patch, and 20% lower power-to-weight ratio, and it was, at worst, within a couple of percent of the all-conquering GT3.
Someone, please figure out how to put the 4.0 engine from the new GT3RS into a Cayman, then come up with aero mods to make it look as aggressive as it really is. Finish it off with some Motons, and I think we'd have a car that would pretty much murder the GT3.
This is all on the objective side. Subjectively, personal preference wins, but in the real world, these cars are effectively identical in all but straight-line power, and if you care about that, buy a Turbo, or a Z06, or a GT-R, or.....
Someone, please figure out how to put the 4.0 engine from the new GT3RS into a Cayman, then come up with aero mods to make it look as aggressive as it really is. Finish it off with some Motons, and I think we'd have a car that would pretty much murder the GT3.
This is all on the objective side. Subjectively, personal preference wins, but in the real world, these cars are effectively identical in all but straight-line power, and if you care about that, buy a Turbo, or a Z06, or a GT-R, or.....
#3
Cool comparo. In the hands of most drivers the two cars would prally be soooo close at the track you couldnt even tell. On the street, the GT3 would win from a "baller" perspective but on a twisty back road i bet the Cayman R would be just as much (if not more) fun --- and youd have an extra 40 grand in your pocket too
#4
In any other country than Germany I'd take the Cayman over the GT3 and save some money. The most fun you can have away from the track are on narrow and curvey roads where you never get up to rly high speeds anyway. I bet on those conditions the Cayman is just more fun.
Sent from my U20i using Teamspeed
Sent from my U20i using Teamspeed
#6
I posted this a few days ago...
https://teamspeed.com/forums/gt/6084...ar-engine.html
As well as dallascajun.
https://teamspeed.com/forums/gt/6083...e-comparo.html
Neither got much exposure though. Awesome review! I think between the two, I'd pick a Boxster Spyder... or may be the GT3.
https://teamspeed.com/forums/gt/6084...ar-engine.html
As well as dallascajun.
https://teamspeed.com/forums/gt/6083...e-comparo.html
Neither got much exposure though. Awesome review! I think between the two, I'd pick a Boxster Spyder... or may be the GT3.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Guy Cosmo
Automobiles
0
06-25-2013 08:53 AM
DJ
458 | 430 | 360
20
06-20-2011 10:32 PM
DJ
Boxster | Cayman
8
03-01-2011 11:55 AM
Bookmarks
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)