Greatest Yankee of All-Time, ok #2
 

Assume that Babe's #1. #2 would be:

1.) Lou Gehrig
2.) Joe D.
3) The Mick
4.) Derek Jeter
5.) Ken Phelps (for the Seinfeld Fans)

Cast your vote.

I like your list, although I'd put Reggie Jackson ahead of Jeter.

Gehrig.

2. Lou
3. Dimaggio
4. Mick
5. Yogi
6. Jeter/Mo


Dhinkle- are you a yankees fan or just like the old timers?

Bernie Williams was far more important to the Yankee Dynasty then Jeter IMO. And for the record I hate the Yankees.

Important but I wouldn't say more...

Yankees suck.

We are big Yankee fans, and yes, he is an old timer that likes old timers. :spar:

Both but grew up a Dodger's fan, hated the
Reggie Jackson" Yanks. Became a fan when Dodgers traded Piazza and Yanks hired Joe Torre.

Since you hate the Yankees, you won't be offended by my comment, what? Fan of Bernie, really good player, borderline for the HOF but more important than Jeter, Derek Jeter?