Notices
Aston Martin | Jaguar | Lotus Vanquish, Vantage, Rapide, DBS, DB9, XKR, Exige, Elise, Esprit, & More Discussion Forum.

Autocar's Sutcliffe on the supercharged Evora: "I’d have one over a Cayman"

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #1  
Old 11-01-2010, 03:35 PM
DJ's Avatar
DJ
DJ is offline
Teamspeed Pro
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Zoo York
Posts: 31,554
DJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond reputeDJ has a reputation beyond repute
Post Autocar's Sutcliffe on the supercharged Evora: "I’d have one over a Cayman"



What is it?

The Evora S is the car that Lotus believes is good enough to be priced above the Porsche Cayman, and only slightly beneath the basic 911 Carrera. Hence it costs £58,995 in 2+2 trim and goes on sale at the end of November.

In the simplest terms it’s a more powerful, faster version of the already excellent base Evora, the extra go arriving courtesy of a supercharged version of that car’s Toyota-sourced 3.5-litre V6. But in reality it is, according to Lotus, “the car we always wanted to build.” In other words the version of the Evora we’ve all been waiting for.

The headline news concerns the more powerful supercharged engine, of course, which now develops a rousing 345bhp at 7000rpm and 295lb ft at 4000rpm – enough muscle to send the 1437kg Evora S to 60mph in a claimed 4.6sec and to 172mph. But there have been improvements made throughout the rest of the car to further improve its dynamic behaviour – and, of course, to justify its £10k premium.

The most significant of these concerns the six-speed manual transmission. This remains as before internally but now features an improved shift mechanism, a lower inertia clutch, new shift cables and a redesigned pedal box to reduce pedal effort. The suspension and steering have also been preened in line with the increased performance, though not, Lotus insists, at the expense of the base car’s exquisite ride quality.

What’s it like?

In a word, brilliant. As suggested, it still rides beautifully, gliding across pockmarked surfaces as if it’s been touched by some Higher Being. It wouldn’t be a Lotus were this not so. But what you really notice, of course, is what happens when you put your foot down – because that’s when the Evora S reveals its true self. The handling and steering seem to crystallise and become even sharper, even more responsive as a result of the extra torque that’s available. After a day at the wheel of this car you realise that the Porsche Cayman is no longer quite so supreme.

In short, the supercharged Evora is one of those cars that, for whatever reason, manages to over-deliver on the sum of its parts on the road. It feels so much more than an Evora with an extra 70bhp.

Not only does it go way harder than before but it sounds, feels and IS hugely more invigorating to drive. The extra engine noise alone makes it seem like a completely different animal on the road. There are rasps and fizzes from the supercharger at low to middling revs that mingle perfectly with the deeper bass sound of the exhaust. As a combination it makes for a truly rousing soundtrack, one that provides just the right accompaniment to the increased performance. Which, by the way, is considerable.

Lotus may claim a 0-60mph time of 4.6sec and 172mph flat out, but between 4000-6000rpm it feels even faster than those numbers suggest. And, thank the lord, the gearchange – though still not squeaky clean above 6000rpm – is approximately 15,000 times better than before. It glides through the gate with a much more precise, mechanical feel, one that actually adds rather than detracts from the car’s appeal.

Even the interior has been much improved, not on the design front but, more significantly, in terms of the way it’s built. A few months ago Lotus poached some key people from Porsche’s quality control department, by all accounts, and already they are making a difference. A fairly big difference if the test car is a typical example.

Should I buy one?

Can’t see why not if you’re in the market for a £60k mid-engined sports car and are only interested in driving the very best. Even amid the bubbling excitement of what’s to come at Lotus, the Evora S is a stand out car right now, a stroke of rare genius.

And if you’re wondering then the answer’s yes; I’d have one over a Cayman any day.


By Steve Sutcliffe
Full images and info -> Lotus Evora S - Road Test First Drive - Autocar.co.uk


 
  #2  
Old 11-01-2010, 04:07 PM
Alzilla's Avatar
Teamspeed Pro
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Minnesota
Posts: 31,976
Alzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond reputeAlzilla has a reputation beyond repute
Wow, I'm surprised by the outcome.

Only downside is that the regular Evora seems to be ~$85-90K here so the Evora S will surely be $100K+ here which is just insane, imo. That's WAY more than the Cayman S or even the upcoming Cayman ClubSport and I don't think Lotus can justify the increase in cost by saying "well we have two back seats!" because those back seats are too small for anything bigger than a gerbil.
 
  #3  
Old 11-01-2010, 04:44 PM
STOPPIE's Avatar
Teamspeed's Howitzer
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 12,273
STOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond repute
$85k+++ for a toyota powered kit car.

Versus, say a hand built 911?


911> any lotus.
 
  #4  
Old 11-01-2010, 04:45 PM
STOPPIE's Avatar
Teamspeed's Howitzer
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 12,273
STOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond repute
ps. pitting the evora against the cayman is stupid. Its not even the same price point of car, nor sytle.
2+2 should be pitted against another 2+2.
 
  #5  
Old 11-02-2010, 06:36 PM
diskreet's Avatar
Teamspeed Senior Member
Join Date: May 2010
Location: PA, USA
Posts: 779
diskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by STOPPIE
911> any lotus.
For you, yes. But not for everyone.

People have very different ideas of what a sports car should be. I want to get a Lotus Elise instead of a Boxster S or even Spyder. That doesn't make me wrong, that just means I want different things from my car.

Modern cars more and more remove the driver from controlling the car, and the 911 is no exception. Yes, they are safer, faster and more comfortable, but at the price of driver involvement. To some that's great. There are still some hardcore people out there, though, that prefer steering feel over painted headlight cleaner covers.


And kit car?
Even the interior has been much improved, not on the design front but, more significantly, in terms of the way it’s built. A few months ago Lotus poached some key people from Porsche’s quality control department, by all accounts, and already they are making a difference. A fairly big difference if the test car is a typical example.
 
  #6  
Old 11-02-2010, 07:45 PM
speedsters's Avatar
Teamspeed Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 159
speedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nicespeedsters is just really nice
Originally Posted by STOPPIE
$85k+++ for a toyota powered kit car.

Versus, say a hand built 911?


911> any lotus.
Please elaborate....
 
  #7  
Old 11-02-2010, 10:34 PM
STOPPIE's Avatar
Teamspeed's Howitzer
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 12,273
STOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by diskreet
For you, yes. But not for everyone.

People have very different ideas of what a sports car should be. I want to get a Lotus Elise instead of a Boxster S or even Spyder. That doesn't make me wrong, that just means I want different things from my car.

Modern cars more and more remove the driver from controlling the car, and the 911 is no exception. Yes, they are safer, faster and more comfortable, but at the price of driver involvement. To some that's great. There are still some hardcore people out there, though, that prefer steering feel over painted headlight cleaner covers.


And kit car?
Have you driven an Evora?

Originally Posted by speedsters
Please elaborate....
911's are hand built. Sure machines press the frame together; but the rest of the car is assembled by hand. Even the paint is sprayed on by hand. (not clear coat or galvinizing material)


Watch ultimate factories: Porsche and you'll see.
 
  #8  
Old 11-04-2010, 07:52 AM
diskreet's Avatar
Teamspeed Senior Member
Join Date: May 2010
Location: PA, USA
Posts: 779
diskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond reputediskreet has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by STOPPIE
Have you driven an Evora?
Honestly, no. But I don't have to. Every review is the same - it's still a Lotus when it comes to driver involvement, feedback and handling.

I guess for the same reason that every time I drive a Porsche I don't like it, you'll never like Lotus. The car doesn't interest you. It doesn't do what you want a car to do.

Originally Posted by STOPPIE
911's are hand built. Sure machines press the frame together; but the rest of the car is assembled by hand. Even the paint is sprayed on by hand. (not clear coat or galvinizing material)


Watch ultimate factories: Porsche and you'll see.
I really need you to explain your logic here. Because 911s are hand built they are amazing sports cars? Because the Evora is hand built it's a kit car?
 
  #9  
Old 11-04-2010, 10:19 AM
Turbogallardo's Avatar
Teamspeed Member
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 219
Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!Turbogallardo You are a Teamspeed member that Rocks!
In my opinion the supercharged Evora S should be the base model and should be priced similarly to a Cayman. The base version is much too slow.
 
  #10  
Old 11-04-2010, 12:47 PM
STOPPIE's Avatar
Teamspeed's Howitzer
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 12,273
STOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond reputeSTOPPIE has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by diskreet
Honestly, no. But I don't have to. Every review is the same - it's still a Lotus when it comes to driver involvement, feedback and handling.

I guess for the same reason that every time I drive a Porsche I don't like it, you'll never like Lotus. The car doesn't interest you. It doesn't do what you want a car to do.

I really need you to explain your logic here. Because 911s are hand built they are amazing sports cars? Because the Evora is hand built it's a kit car?
explain my logic? Porsche sells thousands of cars to Lotus's a few hundred.

Clearly the numbers speak for themselves.

For the Evora; you need to think like MOST of buyers out there in small buyers pool. For $85k usd, what can I get?


A LOT OF OTHER CARS that do FAR more then what the Evora does. Driver involvement? The Evora has a shifting linkage out of a Toyota pick up truck. Ya, that's a lot of engineering. The same power plant that's found in a Camery or ES350. Whoa, hold me back on the engineering. I'm underwhelmed.

Is it a cool looking car? Yes, sure it is. But does it stick out to be a real value for 85k?

No.


I'd rather have a 360 Modena if I didn't want a Porsche. Hand built engine with tons of heritage poured into the car. And oh btw


IT'S A FERRARI!

Not a car tossed together with a Toyota Engine.

Next?
 


Quick Reply: Autocar's Sutcliffe on the supercharged Evora: "I’d have one over a Cayman"



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:28 AM.